In the summer of 2015, Jessica Jane Larson attended her first college party to kick off her senior year in high school along with her twin male friends who were her escort for the night. Little did she know that the aftermath of this party would be the highlight of her entire future to come and the start of complicated relationships with her friends and family. In hopes of destructing her "good-girl image", she succeeded big time after this particular night--she would no longer be considered "pure" in the eyes of God, or her parents. In the process of unraveling new friendships during the remainder of her senior year, she learns that everyone's favorite twins--Jared and Jaiden Daniels--have a few secrets of their own. Now, she must choose between her childhood friends who have been in constant battle over her affection since the night of the party, where it all happened… but how will she choose when they have both been at fault before?